A population health management proposition for the ICB: what South East Wolverhampton would measure, why those measures rather than others, and what the ICB would receive — as aggregate figures with no patient data leaving the neighbourhood.
Wolverhampton does not have a shortage of services. It has ten services around the same person, four life stages with different failure modes, and no shared denominator across any of them. That is a measurement problem before it is a care problem — and it is the reason improvement has been hard to demonstrate here.
Healthy life expectancy, men, against 63.1 in England. Health is lost inside working life, not after it.
Years of life expectancy separating the most and least deprived Wolverhampton wards, for men
Alcohol-related admissions per 100,000, against 1,705 nationally
Of the city aged 18–64 — the cohort with the least routine contact of any
Of residents said more money would most improve their wellbeing — the top answer by a distance
Returned over ten years for every £1 spent on alcohol treatment
| Stage | What actually fails | Where the signal already sits | Who currently holds it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Infants 0–2 | Missed universal contacts generate letters instead of people; infant mortality runs at 5.2 per 1,000 against roughly 3.9 in England | The schedule itself — new birth visit, 6–8 week check, immunisation course, milestone reviews | Health visiting, general practice and child health information systems — rarely reconciled |
| Children 0–18 | Uncontrolled long-term conditions read as attendance problems | School attendance, non-collection of medication | Schools and pharmacy — neither read by a clinician |
| Young people 16–25 | Discharge from a children's service is not admission to an adult one | The gap between two service records | Nobody. This number does not exist in the city. |
| Working adults 25–64 | No routine contact at all until crisis presentation | A&E, alcohol admissions, pharmacy, job centres, care home visits | Each service separately, none linked |
| Frailty 65+ | Six records, no synthesis, contradictions unnoticed | GP, care home, home care, pharmacy, hospital, social care | All six. Never together. |
Wellbeing coverage is far higher in care homes than in people's own homes. What is currently monitored therefore describes the people easiest to reach rather than the population — and anyone with no service contact is invisible by definition. Every improvement figure the system currently produces is calculated on a denominator that excludes the people most likely to be failed.
Skeina's first contribution to population health management is not an intervention. It is an honest denominator.
Set out explicitly so it can be argued with. Each link is a claim, and each claim has a measure attached in the KPI framework below. Where a link is unproven, it is marked as such rather than assumed.
The two right-hand columns are weaker than the two on the left, and we say so. Outputs are directly attributable to Skeina. Outcomes are plausibly influenced. Impact is not attributable at this scale within this timeframe, and any proposal claiming otherwise is inviting a disappointment it has scheduled for itself.
We therefore propose to be held to the output and process tiers, with outcome measures reported but not contracted against in the first two years.
Tiers 1 and 2 are within the neighbourhood team's control and available monthly. Tier 3 is influenced but confounded. Tier 4 is the reason for doing it and cannot be attributed.
| Tier | Measure | Why it earns its place | Source | Cadence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 · coverage | Wellbeing coverage by setting and strand | The honest denominator. Everything else is conditional on it, and it will start poor. | Skeina | Monthly |
| Tier 1 · coverage | People with no routine service contact identified | The invisible cohort, counted for the first time | Skeina | Monthly |
| Tier 1 · coverage | Equity breakdown by ward and deprivation decile | Designed into the first data model, not retrofitted | Skeina | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Referral loop closure rate, by partner | Whether coordination produced anything. Nobody in the city currently holds this number. | Skeina and WIN-listed partners | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Time from need identified to need met | The lived experience of coordination, in days | Skeina | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Transitions where an adult service accepted before the children's service closed | The 16–25 cliff, made visible. Expected to be poor. | Skeina and partners | Quarterly |
| Tier 2 · process | 6–8 week check completion, and days overdue at completion | The first universal contact after birth, covering baby and mother — and a direct infant-mortality-adjacent measure | GP record and CHIS | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Primary immunisation completion at 12 months, by ward | Overdue in the first year means unprotected in the highest-risk months; MMR uptake is below the WHO target | CHIS | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Contradictions surfaced per 1,000 records | Direct safety yield, and the case for the synthesis itself | Skeina audit | Monthly |
| Tier 2 · process | Coordinator send-back and flag rate | Whether the engine is being checked at all. A fall to zero is a warning. | Skeina audit | Monthly |
| Tier 3 · outcome | Mean anticholinergic burden on the frailty register | Directly modifiable, auditable, defensible to CQC | GP record | Quarterly |
| Tier 2 · process | Income secured for residents (£/yr, partner-confirmed) | The one hard-currency line: real pounds into households in the most deprived wards, verified per case — against £24bn unclaimed nationally | Advice partners | Monthly |
| Tier 3 · outcome | Entitlement identified and claimed | Residents named money as the top wellbeing factor, at 47% | Advice partners | Quarterly |
| Tier 3 · outcome | Alcohol treatment engagement after admission | The city's worst indicator and the best evidenced return | Recovery Near You and SUS | Quarterly |
| Tier 3 · outcome | Sensory review within 12 months, frailty register | Most reversible, least connected issue in frail populations | GP record and optometry | Quarterly |
| Tier 4 · impact | Emergency admissions and conveyances per 1,000 | Reported for context. Not attributable and not contracted against. | SUS · WMAS | Annual |
| Tier 4 · impact | Healthy life expectancy gap between wards | The reason for doing any of this. Moves over a decade, not a contract cycle. | OHID | Annual |
This claim is checkable, so here is the check — the closest systems in the world, what each proved, and what each is missing. The honest reading: the pieces are proven separately, the assembly is the innovation, and one famous null result tells us exactly what not to promise.
| System | Scale | What it proved | What it lacks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole Systems Integrated Care North West London | 2.4 million | Linked primary, community, mental health, acute and social care data with dashboards for proactive case-finding is buildable and governable in the NHS | Commissioner-facing at ICS scale. Identifies cohorts; the action on any one person, and whether anything happened next, sits outside it |
| Connected Bradford | 800,000 | Health, education, social care and environment data can be linked across forty years — the education link Skeina's children's strand needs is precedented | A research and planning accelerator, not an operational tool a neighbourhood team works from daily |
| Compassionate Frome Somerset | 28,510 — one practice | The only intervention shown to cut emergency admissions across a whole population: down 14% over 44 months while the rest of Somerset rose 28.5%. Broad identification — “anyone giving cause for concern” — plus care planning plus community connection, using a service directory and connectors | People and paper, one practice, one heroic team. No instrumentation: coverage, loop closure and equity were never measured, so nobody can say which part worked or replicate it reliably |
| Camden Coalition New Jersey | 800 patients, RCT | The cautionary tale: intensive multidisciplinary coordination for the highest-cost patients, tested properly — readmissions 62.3% against 61.7% in usual care. No effect | Targeted the top of the risk pyramid and measured admissions. Both choices failed, and Skeina deliberately makes neither |
| Gesundes Kinzigtal Germany | ~60,000 | All-age, whole-population integration at almost exactly SE Wolverhampton's size, sustained for two decades; enrolled highest-morbidity first; evaluated against matched controls on 126 co-designed indicators | Built on insurer shared-savings contracts with no NHS equivalent, and no VCS or education layer |
| Nuka · Alaska | ~65,000 | Community ownership of the system itself — recipients became owners — identified as the key to two decades of results | A full care system with its own workforce; the ownership principle transfers, the model does not |
| Findhelp · USA | National — 550,000+ programmes | Closed-loop social referral at scale: screen, refer, track, close, report outcomes — embedded in hospital records, used by 600+ systems and whole US states | Vendor-owned, US social-care market, no clinical synthesis and no neighbourhood denominator — the instrumentation without the mechanism |
| Omaolo · Finland | National | Assessment with routing done properly: a CE-marked class IIa medical device, state manufacturer, formal clinical validation — covering health and social-service assessments | Names the price of the assessment layer. We adopt the standard, not the layer — deliberately, until Stage 3 |
| Foundry BC · Canada | Provincial — 12–24s | The 16–25 model: health, mental health, substance use, peer and social support with no referral and no wrong door; 35 centres by 2027 plus a virtual arm | Buildings-first and youth-only; the principle transfers to our Strand B and family hubs, the estate does not |
| Social prescribing platforms UK, various | Practice-level | Referral-outcome tracking into the VCS is commercially proven | One referral type, prescription-shaped, clinician-initiated. No synthesis, no rules, no life-course view, no population denominator |
Camden aimed intensive coordination at the costliest patients and measured admissions: null. Frome worked the whole population with broad identification and community connection, and is the one documented admissions success. The lesson is architectural: go population-wide, connect people to community capacity, and do not stake the case on admissions. Skeina is, in one sentence, Compassionate Frome with instrumentation — the mechanism that worked, made measurable, repeatable and ownable by the neighbourhood rather than dependent on one exceptional team.
| Claim | Who else does it | Why it matters to a commissioner |
|---|---|---|
| 1 · The unit of account is a closed loop, not a risk score — every referral, including into the VCS by WIN identifier, chased to a recorded outcome, published by partner | Social prescribing tools do it for one referral type. Nobody does it cross-sector against a population denominator | It is the difference between “we identified 400 people” and “173 needs met” — the number a commissioner can actually buy |
| 2 · Deterministic, published rules — no model of any kind — 52 rules, each with a named owner, readable by a DPO in a sitting | Everyone else risk-stratifies with proprietary or statistical models | Deployment speed and cost: no medical-device pathway, a light DPIA, and an IG conversation measured in weeks not years |
| 3 · Life-course strands on one register — infants’ universal contacts, school attendance, the 16–25 cliff, working-age outreach and frailty in one architecture | Everything comparable is single-cohort (frailty, SEND, super-utilisers) or all-age but data-only (Bradford) | One coordinator function and one governance serve four cohorts; the marginal strand costs rules, not a new platform |
| 4 · Neighbourhood-owned, asset-locked — a CIC held by the providers and charities it serves | Nuka, in Alaska. No UK coordination platform | Partners share data with infrastructure they co-own in a way they never do with a vendor — ownership is the data-sharing strategy |
Nothing below requires a platform procurement, a data centre or a national integration programme. The first year runs on searches the practices can already do, records the care homes already keep, and a public read-only feed of WIN.
| Step | What | Data needed | New IG required | Funded how |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 · now–12 wks | Retrospective Phase 0: one care home, 30 residents, the frailty rules run against last year | GP record + consented care home records | None new — direct care basis exists | In-kind, H&B |
| 1 · months 3–9 | Prospective frailty + infants strands; the dashboard's first real monthly return; alcohol rule live via discharge lists | Practice searches, CHIS reports practices already receive, WIN public feed | Care home DSA; WIN feed agreement with the council | PCN capacity monies + ICB place innovation |
| 2 · months 6–12 | Family hub front door for 0–18 and 16–25; Project SEEN becomes Strand A's delivery arm | Hub programme data; consented per family | Hub operating procedure + consent model | Family hub / Start for Life programme |
| 3 · months 9–18 | The education link: attendance for consented children with LTCs — the long pole, started early | School attendance, per consented child | Article 26 arrangement with the LA as education authority — Bradford proves it is doable | Council public health / DPH priorities |
| 4 · months 12–24 | Independent evaluation against the co-designed indicator set; decision to scale, change or stop | The audit log itself | Evaluation agreement | NIHR (ARC / HDRC route) or charitable |
Year one is a team, not a technology: one full-time care coordinator, a fractional clinical lead, a fractional analyst, and the rule engine — which is a website and a set of practice searches. A low six-figure annual cost, in the range of a single band 8a post plus sessions, against which the first deliverable is a number the system has never had: how many people the neighbourhood found, and how many needs it met.
An admissions reduction. The one rigorous trial of intensive coordination found none, and the one population that achieved one did it over four years with mechanisms we are only now instrumenting. Admissions are reported in tier 4, openly, uncontracted. If they move, the independent evaluation — not us — gets to say so.
Aggregate only — counts, proportions and medians at neighbourhood and ward level. Cells with a denominator below 10 or a numerator below 5 are suppressed; ward rows are rounded to the nearest 5; no line-level data exists in the return and no route back to an individual is possible. Every figure is produced from the rule engine's own audit log and is reconstructable against the register version stamped on the page.
Open the dashboardEight headline indicators with month-on-month movement and trajectory plans; coverage by cohort; loop closure by partner with breach counts; the infants' universal-contact schedule with the number of missed contacts recovered by a person rather than a letter; ward-level equity with the gap-to-best column; the engine-assurance panel; and the found-people register — the 420 people in six months who appeared in no denominator anywhere. All figures on the demonstration are synthetic and labelled as such.
Performance-managing a neighbourhood team needs denominators, trends and comparisons — all aggregate. Line-level flow would require a separate legal basis and would add nothing the ICB needs for this purpose. Settling that now, in the data-sharing agreement, is the single most common failure point this project can remove in advance.
Two decisions that stop Skeina duplicating what the city already runs.
WIN is the council's own directory, developed with service users, their families and carers, covering social care and support services, children's services, the SEND Local Offer, social and leisure activities, and advice on employment, benefits, keeping healthy and getting about. It already holds what a neighbourhood coordination system would otherwise try to rebuild.
| WIN does this | Skeina does this | |
|---|---|---|
| Holds the list | Yes — maintained by the council, kept current by providers | Never. A second directory is out of date within a year. |
| Says what exists | Yes, for the whole city | No |
| Knows a person needs it | No — the person has to look | Yes, from the record, by published rule |
| Sends a minimised referral | No | Yes — need, setting, access, consent. No diagnosis, no narrative. |
| Knows whether anything happened | No | Yes. This is the part nobody currently does. |
Skeina needs WIN's service records as structured references so a referral can name a real listed service rather than a free-text guess, and so loop closure can be reported back against the same identifier. That is a read-only feed of a public directory — the lightest possible integration, with no personal data involved in either direction.
Family hubs are the only universal front door that working-age adults, children and young people all pass through without being ill. That makes them the natural host for the two strands where clinical contact is rarest — and it is why Project SEEN already sits there rather than in general practice.
| Strand | Family hub role | What Skeina adds |
|---|---|---|
| Children 0–18 | Early help, parenting, SEND Local Offer, the existing Project SEEN relationships | Attendance and LTC signals the hub cannot see, routed with consent |
| Young people 16–25 | Young parents, care leavers, the point where children's services end | The open-transition register and its named owner |
| Working adults 25–64 | The parent at the school gate who has no other contact with the system | Opportunistic Health Check, entitlement and alcohol offers at a non-clinical contact |
Hub staff are not clinicians and must never be placed in a position of clinical judgement. The decision-rights model already handles this — coordinators route by category, clinicians sort by acuity — but it has to be written into the hub's operating procedure rather than assumed, and the escalation route from a hub must reach a duty clinician the same session, not a task queue.
Health & Beyond is both the proposed developer of Skeina and the proposed pilot site. Skeina is being constituted as a community interest company held jointly by Health & Beyond Ltd, local charities and other neighbourhood providers, so that an asset lock — not our good intentions — prevents the neighbourhood's coordination layer becoming any single provider's property. Any evaluation must be independently conducted, and we would expect that to be a condition of support rather than an offer from us.